What if the problem isn’t the message? 

There’s something I’ve been thinking about increasingly as I study psychology alongside my work in brand and communications.

We spend a lot of time thinking about how to make internal communications more effective, from developing better messages and more engaging content to choosing the right channels, timing and leadership narrative. All of that matters, of course, but I wonder whether we’re sometimes starting in the wrong place.

What if the biggest problem with internal communications isn’t what we’re saying, but how little we understand the people we’re saying it to?

People don’t all think in the same way, process information in the same way or respond to it in the same way. Which sounds obvious, doesn’t it? But I’m not sure our communications planning always reflects that reality.

There’s no such thing as the average employee

We often talk about employees as though they’re a reasonably consistent audience, segmenting them by location, role, seniority or whether they’re office-based or frontline. These are all useful distinctions, but what about how people actually think?

Take neurodiversity, for example.

An autistic employee might prefer clear, explicit communication and advance notice of changes, while someone with ADHD might find lengthy, information-heavy communications difficult to navigate but engage more readily with concise, well-structured information. And the picture becomes more complex again with AuDHD. A dyslexic colleague might find a dense written document unnecessarily demanding, even when the thinking behind it is perfectly accessible to them. These are examples, not rules and we shouldn’t assume someone’s diagnosis tells us everything about their communication preferences.

But the point is that the way information is presented can create very different experiences for different people, and those differences aren’t necessarily about intelligence, capability or willingness to engage. They’re about how people attend to, process and interpret information.

Research into cognitive load, for example, has shown that our working memory has limitations (Sweller, 1988). The more unnecessary mental effort we demand of someone, the less capacity they may have available to understand and use the information itself. That’s relevant to everyone, but becomes particularly important when we’re designing communications for people with different cognitive needs.

So why do we still produce so much internal communication that assumes one format, one pace and one way of processing information will work for everyone?

Understanding isn’t the same as receiving

There’s another distinction I think we need to make. We often measure internal communications by whether people have received, opened, read or understood something, but those measures only tell us part of the story.

Imagine announcing a significant organisational change.

One employee reads the announcement and immediately wants to know what it means for their role, while another needs time to process the information before they’re ready to ask questions. Someone else might want to discuss it with their manager or colleagues, while another finds the ambiguity of what’s being proposed far more stressful than the change itself.

The message is identical, but the psychological experience isn’t.

Research into intolerance of uncertainty, including work by Carleton (2016), helps explain why uncertainty can be particularly difficult for some people, although responses vary and context matters. For an employee who already finds ambiguity difficult, a message promising that more details will follow ‘in due course’ might create considerable anxiety. For someone else, it might barely register.

This is where internal communications needs to go beyond simply asking whether a message is clear. Clear to whom? And clear enough for them to do what?

Neurodiversity should change the questions we ask

I think there’s a temptation to approach neurodiversity as an accessibility consideration towards the end of the communications process. We’ve developed the strategy, written the messages and chosen the channels, so now we need to make sure the content is accessible.

But what if we brought that thinking in much earlier?

What if, before developing a communications plan, we considered whether we’re giving people different ways to access and engage with information, whether we’re being explicit about what we know and what happens next, and whether we’re allowing enough time for people to process information and respond?

We might also question our reliance on particular formats, such as lengthy written updates or live presentations, and challenge some of our assumptions about what engagement actually looks like. Someone who doesn’t speak up in a town hall isn’t necessarily disengaged, just as someone who doesn’t respond immediately may simply need more time to think. And someone who asks lots of detailed questions isn’t necessarily being difficult.

Yet how often do we interpret these behaviours through our own expectations of what an engaged employee should look like?

Understanding neurodiversity could help us challenge some many ingrained assumptions about communication and participation, and ultimately make the experience better for everyone.

It goes beyond neurodiversity

Of course, different cognitive needs are only part of the picture. Our experiences, world views, emotions, relationships and sense of identity also influence how we interpret information.

In previous posts, I explored the psychological impact of organisational change, particularly the way redundancies and restructuring can affect trust, belonging and people’s sense of security. Those experiences don’t disappear when the next communications campaign begins.

An employee who’s worried about their future may interpret a leadership message very differently from someone who feels secure and valued. Likewise, someone who identifies strongly with their immediate team, profession or depot might respond differently to a corporate message about organisational identity. Social identity theory, developed by Tajfel and Turner (1979), offers a useful way of understanding how group membership can shape people’s sense of who they are and where they belong.

So perhaps we need to think about employees in a much richer way, not simply as audiences to be reached, but as individuals whose cognitive needs, experiences, relationships and circumstances influence how communications land.

What would we do differently?

For me, this is where the opportunity becomes interesting, because a deeper understanding of psychology shouldn’t simply give us better ways to write messages. It should help us make better decisions about communications in the first place.

We might decide that a major announcement needs to be supported by a clear written summary, a visual explanation, opportunities for discussion and time for people to reflect. We might recognise that some employees need greater certainty about what happens next, while others need more opportunities to influence the outcome.

We might also stop assuming that silence means agreement, that questions mean resistance or that opening an email means understanding it.

And perhaps we’d become more interested in measuring whether people feel informed, included, able to ask questions and equipped to act, rather than simply whether they’ve seen the latest update.

None of this means creating a separate communications plan for every individual, nor does it mean assuming that all neurodivergent employees want the same things. It means designing flexibility into our approach, involving employees in understanding what works for them and recognising that different people may need different things from the same communication. There’s an important distinction here between communicating at people and communicating with an understanding of them.

Perhaps we need to rethink where we start

I don’t think the answer is to make internal communications more complicated. Quite the opposite. It’s about becoming more thoughtful about the complexity that’s already there.

People bring different cognitive needs, preferences, experiences and emotions to work, and all of those things influence how they understand, interpret and respond to communication. And psychology gives us some fascinating ways to explore those differences, but the real value isn’t simply in knowing the theories. It’s in using that understanding to challenge our assumptions and make better decisions.

Because if we’re serious about helping organisations engage their people, build trust and navigate change, surely we need to understand those people a little better first?

Perhaps the next big improvement in internal communications won’t come from finding better ways to deliver the message, but from getting better at understanding the people receiving it.